The gracious folks at one of Orland Park’s excellent elementary schools were kind enough to host about 18 guests for a morning of observation and discussion on their use of Promethean interactive whiteboards for teaching and learning. The event was sponsored by Promethean resellers Graphtech Systems.
After introductions and a brief review of their process of adopting the “P-boards,” as they called them, we observed Kindergarten, 4th grade Music, and 4th grade Math classes for 30 minutes each. Then we returned to the conference room for a review of some new research about the effectiveness of Promethean boards in boosting student achievement and a general Q&A session while we ate lunch.
The demonstrations reminded me of the universal truth that technology tools don’t automatically make a lesson better. The teacher is always the key to good integration.
Using a P-board and handheld clickers to ask kids questions they already know the answers to is just an empty an exercise with the technology as without it. Projecting a textbook page on to a screen so a student can walk up to the front and write an answer on the same answer blank that’s in the book doesn’t make a whole lot of sense to me.
Juxtaposing video clips of old and new dance steps, though, and inviting students to identify and annotate ways in which they compare and contrast, and saving those annotations for sharing online is a much more engaging use of this technology. So is drawing lines of symmetry in large sized polygons and figuring out together why there are more lines of symmetry in an equilateral triangle than an isosceles triangle.
I was also reminded that good technology integration is incremental. It’s natural in a new implementation like this one, now in its first year, for people to start by taking what they’ve been doing in the analog world and moving it into digital space without changing it much. The really good stuff comes later on when the comfort level and confidence improves and teachers have time to share what they’re doing with each other. As they do that, they’ll escalate their practice and become better together than they could be on their own. That’s when it’s the most fun to be a professional educator, in my humble opinion.
Our hosts are off to a great start, mostly because they have their priorities right. The teachers drove this initiative from the beginning and put student learning first. Their Principal and School Board are highly supportive and have made time and money available for ongoing professional development. They picked a product they like and are excited about, and the vendor has kept all promises and worked well with the school.
Many thanks to our hosts for the morning…and best wishes for ongoing success!
Posted on April 14th, 2009 by Curt Lieneck
Filed under: Uncategorized | No Comments »